Tuesday, June 15, 2010

Mind-Boggling Questions

So here are two things I have been contemplating lately.  They are mind-boggling questions that may forever be unanswered, but I will raise them nonetheless.


[SPOILER ALERT]  For those of you who haven't read the Harry Potter series, please skip this post or just don't read the second half (SORRY!)




1.  Superman is supposedly super, right?  He's an alien, for one thing.  He can fly.  He can run really fast.  He's really strong and has x-ray vision and heat emanates from his eyeballs and he can blow really strong winds and stuff.  But he has one weakness - kryptonite.


And everytime Superman fights a bad guy, that bad guy conveniently has some kryptonite with which to disable Superman.  Once Superman is around kryptonite, he becomes this groveling weak little creature that is no more useful than my hamster trying to save the world.


So if Superman is so SUPER, why doesn't he just FLY AROUND THE UNIVERSE (because he can fly) and use his awesome x-ray vision (because he has x-ray vision) and find all the kryptonite, then use his heat laser eyeballs (because he emanates it from his eyes) and DESTROY ALL THE KRYPTONITE??


Then when Bizarro goes to search for some kryptonite to use against Superman (his millionth attempt to defeat Superman), he will discover that gasp! there is none to be found!  And now that Superman has destroyed all the kryptonite, he no longer has a weakness!  Now SUPERMAN can go on the hunt and defeat all those pesky bad guys, and he will be pure pwnage because they have no kryptonite.


But no.  Instead, Superman just idly sits at the Daily Bugle (or wherever he works, I get him and Spider-Man mixed up) waiting for the next bad guy to come along, with more kryptonite, to try and defeat him.  Way to make things easy on yourself, Mr. Kent.  Yeah, that's right.  You could have made the world a safer place a long time ago if you had just used your brain.

2.  So Harry is supposedly the CHOSEN ONE, right?  And since he's the Chosen One, only he can defeat He-Who-Must-Not-Be-Named [okay, I'm feeling brave so I'll start using his name - VOLDEMORT].  Thus, given that Harry Potter is the Chosen One and is the only one who can defeat Voldemort, the most powerful wizard of their time...


SHOULDN'T EVERYONE DO THEIR BEST TO PROTECT HARRY AND MAKE SURE HE REALLY DOES DEFEAT VOLDEMORT???


I'm specifically talking about the ANTI-CLIMATIC scene in Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows, where everyone basically formed a giant circle around Harry and Voldemort and watched them battle it out to the death.  Yeah, sounds reminiscent of high school.


Okay, so everyone is standing around WATCHING them duel.  Harry, a pewny 17-year-old, against the impossibly powerful Voldemort.  No one offers to jump in and help Harry to make sure that Harry doesn't die.  Because after all, why not just stand there, twiddling your thumbs, and watch Harry and Voldemort duel?  


I'm not asking for much.  Maybe someone could, I DON'T KNOW, have shot a hex at Voldemort - like the jelly-legs hex or something - so Harry would at least have a much better chance at winning.  Maybe just help Harry out a little bit by disabling Voldemort. 


BUT WHERE IS THE HONOR IN THAT, you cry.  HARRY HAS TO DEFEAT VOLDEMORT ON HIS OWN!


And to that, I say - WHO GIVES A CRAP ABOUT HONOR WHEN, IF HARRY MESSES UP, HES DEAD AND WITH HIM THE FATE OF THE ENTIRE WIZARDING WORLD IS SEALED?!  I WOULD GLADLY SACRIFICE MY HONOR IF I KNEW THAT IT WOULD GUARANTEE THE DEFEAT OF VOLDEMORT!!!


But no.  Instead, J.K. Rowling had Harry and Voldemort fighting in a duel, surrounded by fully capable wizards who opted instead to ogle Harry and Voldemort rather than try to help Harry out by shooting a few random curses while Voldemort's back was turned. 

3 comments:

  1. First of all. As far as I know, Superman and the Justice League did end up destroying all of the Kryptonite in the universe... Except for one piece that Batman carries, which was given to him because Superman trusts him to use it only in case he goes berserk. I could be wrong though.

    Also, he works at the Daily Planet. Dude just look it up. It took me 2 seconds. Daily Bugle is Spiderman

    As for Harry Potter. If you look at most of the fights that the students get in, they just get rocked by the Death Eaters. Even the DA tends to only get off with just lucky shots and defensive charms. So I imagine that for most of those students (because they were all basically students... all the adults were either fighting Bellatrix or outside or hurt if I remember correctly), if they had fired a spell at Bellatrix or Voldemort, they probably would have had that spell just reflected back at them, or maybe even towards Harry. Knowing this, I'm willing to bet that they were too afraid to do anything or figured that they would end up doing more harm to Harry than good.

    Also, I don't know if you know this, but the nature of someone being called "the Chosen One," it kinda sorta implies that he's the ONLY ONE who can actually do anything. I mean, for crying out loud, the dude was dead and then came back to life. If I was one of the other students there wouldn't be a doubt in my mind that Harry would win the fight.

    And also, that point in the story wasn't the climax... So can you really say that it was Anti-Climactic? I don't think you can call it a climax when at that point you already know how it's going to end. I thought the climax was more when Harry got "killed" and you didn't know what was going to happen. Tho I guess that part was pretty Anti-Climactic as well since he was all of a sudden at King's Cross and it wasn't suspenseful or anything anymore.

    You spelled "puny" wrong also. You wrote "pewny." I certainly hope that word never comes up in your cases.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Dude, if i were one of the students, and so scared of voldemort that i can't say his name, what would i be doing in that circle in the first place? RUN AWAY! I still don't understand why there's a circle... -_-

    If there's a high school fight circle, and one of the kids pulls out a gun, what does the circle do? DISPERSE! or so i'd hope.

    ReplyDelete